Index News Band Songs Fans

 

LATEST

News

Media

New Additions

General Articles

Interviews

Release Reviews

Live Reviews

Daylight Press Kit

Nation Press Kit

Fan Club

 

LEGEND

Art

Band

Charts

Linked

 

MUSIC

Albums

Singles

Songs

Sounds

Tabs

 

FANS

Community

Credits

FAQ

Guestbook

Links

Human Frailty Pty Ltd
2001 - 2010

 

STUFF OEM REVIEW

Summary

Article Text

Comments

 

Summary

Information: Stuff this "One Eyed Man" review from, curiously enough, "Stuff".

Author: Keith Nunes.

Date: March 2001.

Original URL: http://www.stuff.co.nz/inl/index/0,1008,1027121a4500,FF.html

 

Article Text

At least when he was with Hunters and Collectors there was the odd tune that had substance and impetus.

This crock is full of pathetically self-conscious dribble such as: This song is for catching the blood you shed, for there's no escaping the quick and the dead; or People smile I've been told, they live and die and lust for gold.

Except for the rare glimpse of mature and sturdy songwriting, the 12 tracks are child-like – appearing to be cobbled together on scraps of paper and jotted down when Seymour was 14 and unable to produce a coherent and sophisticated thought.

And what does it sound like? That's another oddity. Although there are moments when he sounds like Mark Seymour, mostly he involuntarily sounds like a B-grade Neil Finn and Crowded House.

Mushroom

1 (out of five)

 

Comments

Oh dear.